rewirebio.iobenchmarks
Source

DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07 · Peer-reviewed

DOI: 10.1038/s41587-024-02382-1Original source

What this source contributed

Records in this release that cite this source. A record can cite several sources.

Results

Values as the source printed them. Compare results only under compatible protocols, datasets and metrics.

Model or configurationMetricValueDatasetEvaluation
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)F10.391 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetCNVnator deletion [1,000-5,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision0.752 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetCNVnator deletion [1,000-5,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall0.264 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetCNVnator deletion [1,000-5,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0.618 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [5,000-10,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0.796 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [5,000-10,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0.505 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [5,000-10,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.976 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [10,000-20,0000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.98 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [10,000-20,0000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.972 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [10,000-20,0000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.949 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [20,000-50,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.984 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [20,000-50,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.916 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion [20,000-50,000)
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, >50,000 bp)0.99 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion >50,000
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, >50,000 bp)0.998 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion >50,000
CNVnator comparator (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, >50,000 bp)0.982 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsCNVnator deletion >50,000
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationF10.926 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetDRAGEN CNV+SV deletion1–5kb
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationPrecision0.986 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetDRAGEN CNV+SV deletion1–5kb
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationRecall0.873 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetDRAGEN CNV+SV deletion1–5kb
DRAGEN 4.2 on Phase4 SKY-6200Runtime (full pipeline)1838.5 secondHG002 DRAGEN runtime sampleDRAGEN HG002 Phase4 full pipeline runtime
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)F1NaN fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [1,000-5,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision0 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [1,000-5,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall0 fractionHG002 35× WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletion subsetDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [1,000-5,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)NaN fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [5,000-10,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [5,000-10,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0.01 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [5,000-10,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.941 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [10,000-20,0000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [10,000-20,0000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.888 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [10,000-20,0000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.903 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [20,000-50,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.967 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [20,000-50,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.85 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion [20,000-50,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)F1 (deletions, >50,000 bp)0.996 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion >50,000
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Precision (deletions, >50,000 bp)0.996 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion >50,000
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV-only configuration (Behera et al. Table S4)Recall (deletions, >50,000 bp)0.996 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV) deletion >50,000
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationF1 (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0.966 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [5,000-10,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationPrecision (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [5,000-10,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationRecall (deletions, [5,000-10,000) bp)0.933 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [5,000-10,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationF1 (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.941 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [10,000-20,0000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationPrecision (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [10,000-20,0000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationRecall (deletions, [10,000-20,0000) bp)0.888 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [10,000-20,0000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationF1 (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.952 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [20,000-50,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationPrecision (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [20,000-50,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationRecall (deletions, [20,000-50,000) bp)0.909 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion [20,000-50,000)
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationF1 (deletions, >50,000 bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion >50,000
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationPrecision (deletions, >50,000 bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion >50,000
DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configurationRecall (deletions, >50,000 bp)1 fractionHG002 35x WGS, GIAB SV v0.6 deletions >1 kb, Table S4 length binsDRAGEN4.2 (CNV+SV) deletion >50,000

Claims

Statements this source supports, each with where in the source it was checked.

  • DRAGEN 4.2 CNV+SV configuration: facets.method_types: Facets: method types ["conventional_pipeline"] (Other DRAGEN configurations (cnv-20261009-method-dragen) are conventional_pipeline)
  • DRAGEN 4.2 on Phase4 SKY-6200: facets.method_types: Facets: method types ["conventional_pipeline"] (Other DRAGEN configurations (cnv-20261009-method-dragen) are conventional_pipeline)
  • Evidence summary: diagnostic genomics model execution: Summary Eleven published execution benchmarks are linked, alongside the DRAGEN 4.2 developer total runtime for HG002 (1,838.5 seconds); four are withheld pending source concerns (see the end of this summary), and pretraining compute for NTv3 and HyenaDNA is linked only as outside scope. Of the seven active benchmarks, five measure conventional variant-calling pipelines and two measure genomic foundation models outside any diagnostic workflow: inference on microbial genomes, and fine-tuning and test-set scoring on human eQTL variants. Only the foundation-model benchmarks print repeated runs (five trials for GenomeOcean, three seeds for the Nucleotide Transformer); none reruns a variant-calling pipeline to measure concordance of the calls, none prints variant-calling accuracy in the same table as runtime, and hardware differs within most comparisons, so differences mix software and hardware. On ten WGS samples run by a University of Oslo and Oslo University Hospital group with no declared competing interests (Samarakoon et al. 2025), read mapping plus HaplotypeCaller for NA12878 (47.55x) took 2,317.7 minutes on a CPU-only GATK pipeline, 123.45 minutes with Parabricks on four L4 GPUs, 78.12 on four A100 GPUs, 54.22 on eight H100 GPUs and 60.29 with DRAGEN v4.2. On the same H100 machine, Parabricks DeepVariant took 14.58 minutes for NA12878 with the version the pipeline used (printed 4.1.0-1; Methods say 4.3.0-1) and 16.05 minutes with the updated version (printed 4.3.0-1; Discussion says 4.3.1-1). On one HG002 30x genome on Google Cloud (O'Connell et al. 2023; the authors' employer funded the study and is an NVIDIA, AWS and Google alliance partner), HaplotypeCaller took 38.8 hours and cost 67.9 USD on a 32-vCPU machine and 0.59 hours and 17.5 USD on eight A100 GPUs, while the somatic caller LoFreq cost 8.1 USD on the CPU machine and 19 to 30.1 USD on 2 to 8 A100 GPUs. On Google Cloud machines of similar hourly cost (Franzoso et al. 2025, no declared conflicts), Sentieon DNASeq took 0:14:00 to 0:16:00 per exome at 0.82 to 1.03 USD and 3:00:00 to 3:50:00 per genome at 8.02 to 10.7 USD, and Parabricks Germline on one T4 GPU took 0:10:00 to 0:14:00 per exome at 0.71 to 0.93 USD and 4:06:00 to 4:40:00 per genome at 8.13 to 10.6 USD; costs exclude the Sentieon licence, and two genome runtime cells that cannot be genome runtimes are disputed and left out of these ranges. On human WGS at five read depths on the HPC nodes of a regional genome project (Marangoni et al. 2026; the GeNePi developers, no declared competing interests; one unnamed sample per depth), a 30x genome took 17h with the CPU GATK equivalent and 1h 36m, 42 m and 30m with Parabricks v4.3.0 on two V100, two A100 and four A100 GPUs, and a 100x genome 60h, 6h 30m, 2h 30m and 2h 06m. On one 120-vCPU Azure instance (Hu et al. 2026; all authors employed by Sentieon), DNAscope took 18.9 minutes for 30x Illumina, DNAscope LongRead 41.2 minutes for 30x PacBio HiFi and DNAscope Hybrid 85.8 minutes for 10x PacBio HiFi plus 35x Illumina, at 1.1, 2.5 and 5.2 USD on demand excluding the licence; each pipeline had different input data, so the three are not a ranking. For GenomeOcean on one H100 (Yu et al. 2026; two authors are at the DOE Joint Genome Institute, which develops GenomeOcean; GTDB bacterial genomes; mean and standard deviation over five trials), embedding extraction with the 4B model ran at 21,386 ± 126 input tokens per second with 72.14 GB peak GPU memory in BF16 and 22,401 ± 204 with 67.91 GB with FP8 weights, and generation ran at 1818.79 ± 7.95 generated tokens per second in BF16 and 2169.04 ± 24.30 with FP8 weights, activations and KV cache. On a human eQTL variant classification task (Hegde et al. 2025; Kingston University authors, independent of the model developers; 8,862 test variants), LoRA fine-tuning of Nucleotide Transformer 500M for 5 epochs took 7.53, 7.50 and 7.48 hours over three seeds and scoring the test split 8.49, 8.51 and 8.49 minutes, on GPUs the Methods give as two TITAN Xp; fine-tuning to convergence took approximately 19 hours for the Nucleotide Transformer and around 1 hour per pruned DNABERT-2 model on two Quadro RTX 8000. No active linked result measures variant-calling accuracy against a truth set; the GenomeOcean ARI values score metagenomic binning against GTDB species labels. The four withheld studies are Zheng et al. 2026 (Clair3 developers; Clair3 and DeepVariant on HG003 long reads), whose supplementary runtimes, DeepVariant version and DeepVariant accuracy differ from its Results text and whose accuracy uses one GIAB sample's v4.2.1 confident regions, which leave out the hardest regions; Aspidova et al. 2026 (ModernGENA and GENA-LM developers; four DNA language model families on one A100), whose printed tokens per second are far too low for its batch sizes; Pearce et al. 2026 (EVEE developers, three of whom co-authored Evo 2; Evo 2 embedding extraction for all ClinVar variants), whose source carries a concern about another figure; and Dalla-Torre et al. 2025 (Nucleotide Transformer developers; IA3 fine-tuning time), whose Methods fine-tuning times conflict with its Discussion. Apart from the five GenomeOcean trials and the three Nucleotide Transformer seeds, each comparison prints one value per sample and set-up on at most ten samples, and costs are list prices at the time of each study. (amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: result amp-result-dragen-hg002-phase4-runtime; model-execution-20261009-source-samarakoon2025-supplement: Supplementary Tables S1 and S3; model-execution-20261009-source-oconnell2023: Table 1; model-execution-20261009-source-franzoso2025-table-s2: Table S2; articles: Methods, Discussion, Funding and Conflicts of interest; model-execution-20261011-source-marangoni2026-genepi-supplement: Table S1; model-execution-20261011-source-marangoni2026-genepi: Competing interest; model-execution-20261011-source-hu2026-dnascope-hybrid: Table 2, Conflict of interest; model-execution-20261011-source-yu2026-fp8-genomeocean: Tables 3 and 4, author affiliations; gfm-guide-20261014-source-hegde2025: Table A1, Methods paragraph 3, Appendices A.2 and A.3, author affiliations)
  • Evidence summary: diagnostic genomics model execution: value: Claimed value Eight published execution benchmarks are linked, alongside the DRAGEN 4.2 developer total runtime for HG002 (1,838.5 seconds); two are withheld pending source concerns (see the end of this summary). Of the six active benchmarks, five measure conventional variant-calling pipelines and one measures inference of a genomic foundation model on microbial genomes, outside any diagnostic workflow. Only the foundation-model benchmark prints spread over repeated runs (five trials); none reruns a variant-calling pipeline to measure concordance of the calls, none prints variant-calling accuracy in the same table as runtime, and hardware differs within most comparisons, so differences mix software and hardware. On ten WGS samples run by a University of Oslo and Oslo University Hospital group with no declared competing interests (Samarakoon et al. 2025), read mapping plus HaplotypeCaller for NA12878 (47.55x) took 2,317.7 minutes on a CPU-only GATK pipeline, 123.45 minutes with Parabricks on four L4 GPUs, 78.12 on four A100 GPUs, 54.22 on eight H100 GPUs and 60.29 with DRAGEN v4.2. On the same H100 machine, Parabricks DeepVariant took 14.58 minutes for NA12878 with the version the pipeline used (printed 4.1.0-1; Methods say 4.3.0-1) and 16.05 minutes with the updated version (printed 4.3.0-1; Discussion says 4.3.1-1). On one HG002 30x genome on Google Cloud (O'Connell et al. 2023; the authors' employer funded the study and is an NVIDIA, AWS and Google alliance partner), HaplotypeCaller took 38.8 hours and cost 67.9 USD on a 32-vCPU machine and 0.59 hours and 17.5 USD on eight A100 GPUs, while the somatic caller LoFreq cost 8.1 USD on the CPU machine and 19 to 30.1 USD on 2 to 8 A100 GPUs. On Google Cloud machines of similar hourly cost (Franzoso et al. 2025, no declared conflicts), Sentieon DNASeq took 0:14:00 to 0:16:00 per exome at 0.82 to 1.03 USD and 3:00:00 to 3:50:00 per genome at 8.02 to 10.7 USD, and Parabricks Germline on one T4 GPU took 0:10:00 to 0:14:00 per exome at 0.71 to 0.93 USD and 4:06:00 to 4:40:00 per genome at 8.13 to 10.6 USD; costs exclude the Sentieon licence, and two genome runtime cells that cannot be genome runtimes are disputed and left out of these ranges. On human WGS at five read depths on the HPC nodes of a regional genome project (Marangoni et al. 2026; the GeNePi developers, no declared competing interests; one unnamed sample per depth), a 30x genome took 17h with the CPU GATK equivalent and 1h 36m, 42 m and 30m with Parabricks v4.3.0 on two V100, two A100 and four A100 GPUs, and a 100x genome 60h, 6h 30m, 2h 30m and 2h 06m. On one 120-vCPU Azure instance (Hu et al. 2026; all authors employed by Sentieon), DNAscope took 18.9 minutes for 30x Illumina, DNAscope LongRead 41.2 minutes for 30x PacBio HiFi and DNAscope Hybrid 85.8 minutes for 10x PacBio HiFi plus 35x Illumina, at 1.1, 2.5 and 5.2 USD on demand excluding the licence; each pipeline had different input data, so the three are not a ranking. For GenomeOcean on one H100 (Yu et al. 2026; two authors are at the DOE Joint Genome Institute, which develops GenomeOcean; GTDB bacterial genomes; mean and standard deviation over five trials), embedding extraction with the 4B model ran at 21,386 ± 126 input tokens per second with 72.14 GB peak GPU memory in BF16 and 22,401 ± 204 with 67.91 GB with FP8 weights, and generation ran at 1818.79 ± 7.95 generated tokens per second in BF16 and 2169.04 ± 24.30 with FP8 weights, activations and KV cache. No active linked result measures variant-calling accuracy against a truth set; the GenomeOcean ARI values score metagenomic binning against GTDB species labels. The two withheld studies are Zheng et al. 2026 (Clair3 developers; Clair3 and DeepVariant on HG003 long reads), whose supplementary runtimes, DeepVariant version and DeepVariant accuracy differ from its Results text and whose accuracy uses one GIAB sample's v4.2.1 confident regions, which leave out the hardest regions; and Aspidova et al. 2026 (ModernGENA and GENA-LM developers; four DNA language model families on one A100), whose printed tokens per second are far too low for its batch sizes. Apart from the five GenomeOcean trials, each comparison prints one value per sample and set-up on at most ten samples, and costs are list prices at the time of each study. (amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: result amp-result-dragen-hg002-phase4-runtime; model-execution-20261009-source-samarakoon2025-supplement: Supplementary Tables S1 and S3; model-execution-20261009-source-oconnell2023: Table 1; model-execution-20261009-source-franzoso2025-table-s2: Table S2; articles: Methods, Discussion, Funding and Conflicts of interest; model-execution-20261011-source-marangoni2026-genepi-supplement: Table S1; model-execution-20261011-source-marangoni2026-genepi: Competing interest; model-execution-20261011-source-hu2026-dnascope-hybrid: Table 2, Conflict of interest; model-execution-20261011-source-yu2026-fp8-genomeocean: Tables 3 and 4, author affiliations)
  • Evidence summary: Select a copy-number variant detection and characterisation workflow: Summary On HG002 deletions, DRAGEN 4.2 with SV-informed CNV calling found 87 to 100% of deletions in every size bin, with precision 0.99 to 1.00; this is the developers' own benchmark. CNVnator matched it above 10 kb but found only 26% of deletions of 1 to 5 kb and 51% of 5 to 10 kb. On NA12878, LUMPY, DELLY and Manta recovered 88 to 94% of known CNVs, but only 20 to 33% of their calls matched; Manta and CNVnator were used to build this truth set, which can favour them. The other callers recovered 1 to 43%. Hwang et al. (2026) compared four exome callers with chromosomal microarray CNVs in 39 clinical exomes, scoring deletion and duplication exons together: sensitivity and PPV were 0.758 and 0.025 for ExomeDepth, 0.662 and 0.096 for CNVkit, 0.768 and 0.239 for CoNIFER and 0.170 and 0.041 for cn.MOPS. The truth set keeps only array CNVs with at least ten probes that overlap exome baits, so any other exon call counts as a false positive. After the authors removed regions where each tool called CNVs in more than 10% of the same 180-exome cohort, ExomeDepth reached 0.903 and 0.102 on a smaller reference set of 2,124 exons (Table 4); this filter is the authors' own method. For characterisation, Zhang et al. (2026) ran five automated ACMG classifiers on 3,031 expert-classified CNVs: five-category accuracy, averaged across classes in a way the paper does not state, ranged from 48.76% (X-CNV) to 69.81% (MarCNV-ISV) (Table 3). With likely and definite classes merged, every tool recognised more pathogenic deletions than pathogenic duplications (AnnotSV 95.16% versus 86.39%) (Table 4). Two of the three authors developed dbCNV and the reference includes their own laboratory's cases, so the dbCNV results are author-reported. None of the comparisons shown reports duplication detection separately, none covers tumour samples or long reads, and none evaluates a foundation model. (amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: sheet 'S4 CNV benchmarking' rows 6-10; cnv-20261009-source-gabrielaite2021-table-s2: rows with sample GB-WGS-NA12878; cnv-20261011-hwang2026-source-article: Table 4; Methods 2.2 and 2.5; cnv-20261011-zhang2026-source-article: Tables 3 and 4)
  • Relevance of HG002 DRAGEN full single-genome runtime on Phase4 to "Select an execution workflow for large-scale diagnostic genomics": Assessed by HG002 DRAGEN full single-genome runtime on Phase4 (amp-source-dragen: See clinical/claims.csv and clinical/sources.md in data/omics/use-case-coverage-amp-20261007/; amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: See clinical/claims.csv and clinical/sources.md in data/omics/use-case-coverage-amp-20261007/)
  • Relevance of HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion [5,000-10,000) bp (DRAGEN Table S4) to "Select a copy-number variant detection and characterisation workflow": Assessed by HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion [5,000-10,000) bp (DRAGEN Table S4) (amp-source-dragen: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md; amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md)
  • Relevance of HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion [10,000-20,0000) bp (DRAGEN Table S4) to "Select a copy-number variant detection and characterisation workflow": Assessed by HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion [10,000-20,0000) bp (DRAGEN Table S4) (amp-source-dragen: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md; amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md)
  • Relevance of HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion [20,000-50,000) bp (DRAGEN Table S4) to "Select a copy-number variant detection and characterisation workflow": Assessed by HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion [20,000-50,000) bp (DRAGEN Table S4) (amp-source-dragen: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md; amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md)
  • Relevance of HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion >50,000 bp (DRAGEN Table S4) to "Select a copy-number variant detection and characterisation workflow": Assessed by HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion >50,000 bp (DRAGEN Table S4) (amp-source-dragen: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md; amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: See data/omics/use-case-coverage-cnv-20261009/claims.csv and sources.md)
  • Relevance of HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion 1–5kb F-score to "Select a copy-number variant detection and characterisation workflow": Assessed by HG002 GIAB v0.6 CNV deletion 1–5kb F-score (amp-source-dragen: See clinical/claims.csv and clinical/sources.md in data/omics/use-case-coverage-amp-20261007/; amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables: See clinical/claims.csv and clinical/sources.md in data/omics/use-case-coverage-amp-20261007/)

Models, benchmarks and other records

Methods (2)

Configurations (4)

Protocols (6)

Datasets (3)

Evaluations (16)

Use cases (2)

Evidence

Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.

Evidence table

Inspect claims, sources and review details

Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.

One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.

27 evidence rows matching the loaded filters

Claims, original sources and review scope · Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb
Property and statementOriginal source and locationReview and provenance
Archive note
Compact curator factual receipt; original retrieved bytes preserved privately; original_artifact_sha256 remains the primary source digest.
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.archive_note

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Archive sha256
84e4295ef87fa0118c5b4d90cbd2f0601e611903eca6c377659e65b902fed457
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.archive_sha256

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Archive transformation receipt
data/omics/amp-coverage-20261007/archive-transformation.json
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.archive_transformation_receipt

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Artifact format
curator_factual_receipt
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.artifact_format

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Artifact SHA-256
edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.artifact_sha256

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Artifact url
https://media.springernature.com/original/springer-static/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41587-024-02382-1/MediaObjects/41587_2024_2382_MOESM3_ESM.xlsx
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.artifact_url

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Compressed artifact sha256
84e4295ef87fa0118c5b4d90cbd2f0601e611903eca6c377659e65b902fed457
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.compressed_artifact_sha256

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Doi
10.1038/s41587-024-02382-1
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.doi

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Licence
Article CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0; unchanged research archive, no unrestricted redistribution asserted
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.licence

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

Media type
application/json
Source metadata
DRAGEN supplementary tables 1–17

Original source ↗

No field-specific location recorded

Version: MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
Retrieved: 2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00

catalogued

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.media_type

Source artifact SHA-256: edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: curator_factual_receipt

Inspected artifact

How to read the evidence

Sources and history

Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Record review: source checked

Scoped author-reported evidence candidate; no clinical recommendation.

Release history

No supporting source is linked yet.

Read original source

Download this release (gzip)
Technical metadata and extraction receipts

Stable ID: amp-source-dragen-supplementary-tables

areas
dna-genomes
contexts
clinical_research
archive note
Compact curator factual receipt; original retrieved bytes preserved privately; original_artifact_sha256 remains the primary source digest.
archive sha256
84e4295ef87fa0118c5b4d90cbd2f0601e611903eca6c377659e65b902fed457
archive transformation receipt
data/omics/amp-coverage-20261007/archive-transformation.json
artifact format
curator_factual_receipt
artifact sha256
edf36c4d94f2f68ce26fe2d7edfb0dfdc8e4d1774367ff10551dc32cc280b74e
artifact url
https://media.springernature.com/original/springer-static/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41587-024-02382-1/MediaObjects/41587_2024_2382_MOESM3_ESM.xlsx
compressed artifact sha256
84e4295ef87fa0118c5b4d90cbd2f0601e611903eca6c377659e65b902fed457
doi
10.1038/s41587-024-02382-1
licence
Article CC-BY-NC-ND-4.0; unchanged research archive, no unrestricted redistribution asserted
media type
application/json
original artifact sha256
c8d66e8373f22382f1c5e4a576d2c85825a18232a14767d239966bc8ab56c3d9
publication status
peer_reviewed
retrieved at
2026-10-07T12:25:22.006309+00:00
review artifact
data/omics/amp-coverage-20261007/methylation-cnv-operations/artifacts/dragen-supplementary-tables.xlsx.gz.facts.json.gz
review artifact format
curator_factual_receipt
review artifact matches original artifact sha256
false
url
https://media.springernature.com/original/springer-static/esm/art%3A10.1038%2Fs41587-024-02382-1/MediaObjects/41587_2024_2382_MOESM3_ESM.xlsx
version
MOESM3 XLSX retrieved 2026-10-07
source locator
Compact curator-selected facts; per-result exact primary locators retained. Original retrieved source bytes identified by original_artifact_sha256.
Related records

    Suggest a correction