Dataset subset

marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly

Source-defined subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly. Exact membership and scoring coverage remain as reported in the cited artifact.

Research readiness

These checks assess whether the evidence supports a reproducible investigation. A source-checked score alone does not meet these requirements.

Release 2026-09-29-06401fd5b220 · Evidence verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Replay metrics

Exact outcomes, predictions, identifiers and evaluator are connected.

Missing or unresolved evidence

No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
artifact hashes: verification is missing
join integrity: verification is missing
score semantics: verification is missing
metric replay: verification is missing

Verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Investigate discrepancies

Replay evidence includes annotations and an assessment of dependence. Unknown independence permits descriptive analysis only.

Missing or unresolved evidence

No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
artifact hashes: verification is missing
join integrity: verification is missing
score semantics: verification is missing
metric replay: verification is missing
annotations: verification is missing
dependence: verification is missing

Verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Run locally

A pinned recipe describes the inputs, environment and resource requirements.

Missing or unresolved evidence

No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
artifact hashes: verification is missing
join integrity: verification is missing
score semantics: verification is missing
recipe pinned: verification is missing
resource estimate: verification is missing

Verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Validate independently

Separate data and exposure records support an independent test.

Missing or unresolved evidence

No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
artifact hashes: verification is missing
join integrity: verification is missing
score semantics: verification is missing
independent validation: verification is missing
overlap checked: verification is missing

Verified: Not verified

Readiness describes the evidence in this release. Availability on your computer is checked separately when an investigation runs. Existing data exposure can prevent independent validation even when files are available.

Artifacts and reproduction

No verified artifact manifest is connected to this record yet. The gaps above identify what is needed before analysis can begin.

Read reviewed discrepancy investigations

Evaluation results

16 evaluations · 256 results. Different protocols are not a single leaderboard.

Filter evaluations

Tested model or methodProtocolDatasetEvaluation setupMetricEvidence origin

Applied filters: All linked evaluations

Source checking is not independent reproduction. Release 2026-09-29-06401fd5b220.

Subset and evaluation context

This record describes a particular subset or cohort used in an evaluation. Its results do not describe the full dataset.

Evidence

Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.

Evidence table

Inspect claims, sources and review details

Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.

One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.

3 evidence rows matching the loaded filters

Claims, original sources and review scope · Release 2026-09-29-06401fd5b220
Property and statement	Original source and location	Review and provenance
attributes.source_locator line 2; Tool=Gold standard; column Accuracy (bp) Context-only references	CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca Original source ↗ line 2; Tool=Gold standard; column Accuracy (bp) Version: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca Retrieved: 2026-09-19	not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit details Field: `attributes.source_locator` Source artifact SHA-256: `f08245658a243f36caedcfb1faebed1ca14dcc33a71f148981f634bc43e8f8a0` Hash scope: Exact downloaded bytes, before optional gzip storage Inspected artifact
description Source-defined subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly. Exact membership and scoring coverage remain as reported in the cited artifact. Context-only references	CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca Original source ↗ line 2; Tool=Gold standard; column Accuracy (bp) Version: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca Retrieved: 2026-09-19	not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit details Field: `description` Source artifact SHA-256: `f08245658a243f36caedcfb1faebed1ca14dcc33a71f148981f634bc43e8f8a0` Hash scope: Exact downloaded bytes, before optional gzip storage Inspected artifact
name marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Context-only references	CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca Original source ↗ line 2; Tool=Gold standard; column Accuracy (bp) Version: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca Retrieved: 2026-09-19	not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit details Field: `name` Source artifact SHA-256: `f08245658a243f36caedcfb1faebed1ca14dcc33a71f148981f634bc43e8f8a0` Hash scope: Exact downloaded bytes, before optional gzip storage Inspected artifact

All evidence (CSV)All evidence (JSONL)How to read the evidence

Sources and history

View linked audit checks and correction history

Release 2026-09-29-06401fd5b220 · Record review: discovered

1 source records and release history

CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · Original source · 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca

Download this release

Technical metadata and extraction receipts

Stable ID: acquired-dataset-b3002a2c940171eead1a

source locator: line 2; Tool=Gold standard; column Accuracy (bp)
missing metadata: split manifest: unextracted

Related records

Suggest a correction

Exact evaluated configurations and original reported results
Tested configuration	Protocol and dataset	Finding	Evidence and details
Configuration: MetaBinner 1.0 (B1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.608 Average completeness (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.014403632321349544; source column: Std error of av. completeness (bp) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBinner 1.0 (B1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 6; Tool=MetaBinner 1.0 (B1); column Average completeness (bp)
Configuration: MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.177 Adjusted Rand index (seq) dimensionless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 5; Tool=MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3); column Adjusted Rand index (seq)
Configuration: UltraBinner 1.0 (E1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.876 Adjusted Rand index (bp) dimensionless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source UltraBinner 1.0 (E1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 12; Tool=UltraBinner 1.0 (E1); column Adjusted Rand index (bp)
Configuration: MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.492 F1 score (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 3; Tool=MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A1); column F1 score (bp)
Configuration: UltraBinner 1.0 (E1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.714 Percentage of binned bp fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source UltraBinner 1.0 (E1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 12; Tool=UltraBinner 1.0 (E1); column Percentage of binned bp
Configuration: Vamb fa045c0 (J1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.556 Average completeness (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.015359501805006384; source column: Std error of av. completeness (bp) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source Vamb fa045c0 (J1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 17; Tool=Vamb fa045c0 (J1); column Average completeness (bp)
Configuration: CONCOCT 0.4.1 (G2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.804 Percentage of binned bp fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source CONCOCT 0.4.1 (G2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 16; Tool=CONCOCT 0.4.1 (G2); column Percentage of binned bp
Configuration: MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.345 Average completeness (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.014372468036824378; source column: Std error of av. completeness (bp) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 5; Tool=MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3); column Average completeness (bp)
Configuration: MaxBin 2.2.7 (F1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.454 F1 score (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MaxBin 2.2.7 (F1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 13; Tool=MaxBin 2.2.7 (F1); column F1 score (seq)
Configuration: MetaWRAP 1.2.3 (D1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.706 Purity (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaWRAP 1.2.3 (D1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 11; Tool=MetaWRAP 1.2.3 (D1); column Purity (bp)
Configuration: MetaBinner 1.0 (B1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.381 Adjusted Rand index (seq) dimensionless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBinner 1.0 (B1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 6; Tool=MetaBinner 1.0 (B1); column Adjusted Rand index (seq)
Configuration: MaxBin 2.2.7 (F1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.485 Average purity (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.015915380604604554; source column: Std error of av. purity (seq) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MaxBin 2.2.7 (F1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 13; Tool=MaxBin 2.2.7 (F1); column Average purity (seq)
Configuration: MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.544 Completeness (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 14; Tool=MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2); column Completeness (bp)
Configuration: MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.527 Purity (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 14; Tool=MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2); column Purity (seq)
Configuration: MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.451 F1 score (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 14; Tool=MaxBin 2.0.2 (F2); column F1 score (seq)
Configuration: Autometa cami2-146383e (C1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.401 Average completeness (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.014033596091873091; source column: Std error of av. completeness (seq) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source Autometa cami2-146383e (C1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 9; Tool=Autometa cami2-146383e (C1); column Average completeness (seq)
Configuration: MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.384 F1 score (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 5; Tool=MetaBAT 0.25.4 (A3); column F1 score (seq)
Configuration: MetaBinner 1.0 (B3)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.766 Adjusted Rand index (bp) dimensionless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBinner 1.0 (B3) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 8; Tool=MetaBinner 1.0 (B3); column Adjusted Rand index (bp)
Configuration: MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.403 F1 score (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 4; Tool=MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2); column F1 score (seq)
Configuration: MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.318 Accuracy (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 4; Tool=MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2); column Accuracy (bp)
Configuration: MetaBinner 1.0 (B1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.126 Completeness (seq) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBinner 1.0 (B1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 6; Tool=MetaBinner 1.0 (B1); column Completeness (seq)
Configuration: CONCOCT 0.4.1 (G2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.689 Average purity (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.015617786994356736; source column: Std error of av. purity (bp) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source CONCOCT 0.4.1 (G2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 16; Tool=CONCOCT 0.4.1 (G2); column Average purity (bp)
Configuration: MetaWRAP 1.2.3 (D1)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.901 Percentage of binned bp fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaWRAP 1.2.3 (D1) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 11; Tool=MetaWRAP 1.2.3 (D1); column Percentage of binned bp
Method: Gold standard	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	1 Average completeness (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: kind: standard_error; printed value: 0.0; source column: Std error of av. completeness (bp) Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source Gold standard · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 2; Tool=Gold standard; column Average completeness (bp)
Configuration: MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2)	Protocol: CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly Dataset subset: marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly	0.797 Purity (bp) fraction · higher Uncertainty: Not reported Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible	Independent external evaluation · Source checked Methods, coverage and source MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2) · CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded · marmgCAMI2_short_read_pooled_gold_standard_assembly CAMI II marine genome binning; pooled short-read gold-standard assembly; circular elements excluded Aggregation: source aggregate over pooled assembly, not sample averaging CAMI: 501b543f65d62e5c1d6c3813be0badcac5e079ca · line 4; Tool=MetaBAT 2.13-33 (A2); column Purity (bp)