| Configuration: Gene-level logistic regression (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Gene-level logistic regression under 5-fold GroupKFold by perturbation (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.942 AUROC (cross-validated AUROC over perturbation-gene pairs, 5-fold GroupKFold by perturbation) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Author-reported evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceGene-level logistic regression on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-incremental-value-lr Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (ii): 'Gene-level features alone achieve AUROC = 0.942 under 5-fold GroupKFold CV' |
|---|
| Configuration: Gene-level logistic regression plus attention edge (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Gene-level logistic regression under 5-fold GroupKFold by perturbation (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.0001 AUROC difference (Gene-level features plus attention edge minus gene-level features only (gene-level logistic regression); cross-validated AUROC over perturbation-gene pairs, 5-fold GroupKFold by perturbation) unitless · higher Uncertainty: 95% CI 0.0001 to 0.0001. Interval type printed as '95% CI' without naming bootstrap; Methods 'Statistical framework': bootstrap CIs use 200 iterations with perturbation-level resampling unless otherwise noted Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Author-reported evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceGene-level logistic regression plus attention edge on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-incremental-value-lr Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (ii): 'adding attention yields ∆AUROC = +0.0001 [95% CI: +0.0001, +0.0001]' |
|---|
| Configuration: Gene-level logistic regression plus correlation edge (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Gene-level logistic regression under 5-fold GroupKFold by perturbation (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | −0.0006 AUROC difference (Gene-level features plus correlation edge minus gene-level features only (gene-level logistic regression); cross-validated AUROC over perturbation-gene pairs, 5-fold GroupKFold by perturbation) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Author-reported evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceGene-level logistic regression plus correlation edge on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-incremental-value-lr Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (ii): 'while adding correlation yields ∆AUROC = −0.0006' |
|---|
| Configuration: Target-gene dropout rate baseline (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Perturbation-first AUROC, RPE1 CRISPRi (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.797 AUROC (per-perturbation AUROC for DE targets, summarised over perturbations; RPE1 CRISPRi) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Independent external evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceTarget-gene dropout rate baseline on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-pf-rpe1-crispri Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (i): 'variance AUROC = 0.866, mean expression = 0.851, dropout = 0.797 vs. attention = 0.747 and correlation = 0.658' |
|---|
| Configuration: Target-gene mean expression baseline (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Perturbation-first AUROC, RPE1 CRISPRi (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.851 AUROC (per-perturbation AUROC for DE targets, summarised over perturbations; RPE1 CRISPRi) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Independent external evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceTarget-gene mean expression baseline on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-pf-rpe1-crispri Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (i): 'variance AUROC = 0.866, mean expression = 0.851, dropout = 0.797 vs. attention = 0.747 and correlation = 0.658' |
|---|
| Configuration: Target-gene variance baseline (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Perturbation-first AUROC, RPE1 CRISPRi (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.866 AUROC (per-perturbation AUROC for DE targets, summarised over perturbations; RPE1 CRISPRi) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Independent external evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceTarget-gene variance baseline on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-pf-rpe1-crispri Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (i): 'variance AUROC = 0.866, mean expression = 0.851, dropout = 0.797 vs. attention = 0.747 and correlation = 0.658' |
|---|
| Configuration: Geneformer V2-316M attention edges, layer not stated (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Perturbation-first AUROC, RPE1 CRISPRi (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.747 AUROC (per-perturbation AUROC for DE targets, summarised over perturbations; RPE1 CRISPRi) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Independent external evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceGeneformer V2-316M attention edges, layer not stated on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-pf-rpe1-crispri Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (i): 'variance AUROC = 0.866, mean expression = 0.851, dropout = 0.797 vs. attention = 0.747 and correlation = 0.658' |
|---|
| Configuration: Absolute Spearman correlation edges (Kendiukhov 2026) | Protocol: Perturbation-first AUROC, RPE1 CRISPRi (Kendiukhov 2026) Dataset subset: Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery (Kendiukhov 2026) | 0.658 AUROC (per-perturbation AUROC for DE targets, summarised over perturbations; RPE1 CRISPRi) unitless · higher Uncertainty: Not reported by the source Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible | Independent external evaluation · Source checkedMethods, coverage and sourceAbsolute Spearman correlation edges on Replogle genome-scale CRISPRi, RPE1, 1,167 perturbations, confound battery gfm-guides-20261014-kendiukhov2026-protocol-pf-rpe1-crispri Aggregation: Not reported Systematic evaluation of single-cell foundation model interpretability: attention-derived edge scores add no incremental value over gene-level features for perturbation-target prediction (Kendiukhov 2026, BMC Genomics 27:634) · Page 10, 'Cross-cell-type generalisation of confound pattern', item (i): 'variance AUROC = 0.866, mean expression = 0.851, dropout = 0.797 vs. attention = 0.747 and correlation = 0.658' |
|---|