BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1)
arXiv (cs.AI) · 2026 · arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 · Preprint
What this source contributed
Records in this release that cite this source. A record can cite several sources.
Results
Values as the source printed them. Compare results only under compatible protocols, datasets and metrics.
| Model or configuration | Metric | Value | Dataset | Evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort | Success rate (aggregate single-attempt score over all 65 tasks, task-weighted 50/65 protocol development and 15/65 construct design; mid reasoning tier, the middle of this system's three settings) | 15.5 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort | Success rate (construct-design pass rate at a single attempt, pass at a final score of at least 0.9, deterministic grading on five tasks and deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score on ten; mid reasoning tier, the middle of this system's three settings) | 24.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass rate at a single attempt (pass@1), simulator-graded and binary per attempt; mid reasoning tier, the middle of this system's three settings) | 13.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort | Success rate (aggregate single-attempt score over all 65 tasks, task-weighted 50/65 protocol development and 15/65 construct design; low reasoning tier, the lowest of this system's three settings) | 10.6 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort | Success rate (construct-design pass rate at a single attempt, pass at a final score of at least 0.9, deterministic grading on five tasks and deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score on ten; low reasoning tier, the lowest of this system's three settings) | 16.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass rate at a single attempt (pass@1), simulator-graded and binary per attempt; low reasoning tier, the lowest of this system's three settings) | 9.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (aggregate single-attempt score over all 65 tasks, task-weighted 50/65 protocol development and 15/65 construct design; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 16.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (construct-design pass rate at a single attempt, pass at a final score of at least 0.9, deterministic grading on five tasks and deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score on ten; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 17.3 percent | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass rate at a single attempt (pass@1), simulator-graded and binary per attempt; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 15.6 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 1/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: AG/AP1 chimera plasmid |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Alkaloid-pathway GoldenBraid set |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Detector choice from antibody data |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Dual-luciferase frame panel |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 1/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: GFP into EcoFlex vector |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin intermediate construct |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin two-chain constructs |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 4/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Matched promoter panel |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Minimal-edit recoding |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 3/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: MPRA construct rebuild |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Prime-assembly donor family |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 3/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Reporter choice from data |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Sodium-channel promoter repair |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Synthetic-chromosome locus edit |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 1/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Tus/TerB HEK293 constructs |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass@5: probability that at least one of 5 attempts passes; best-of-k, never comparable with single-attempt pass rate; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 42.5 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning protocol development, pass@5 |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass@10: probability that at least one of 10 attempts passes; best-of-k, never comparable with single-attempt pass rate; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 60.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning protocol development, pass@10 |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (protocol-development tasks solved at least once in ten attempts, out of 50; a coverage count under repeated sampling, not a single-attempt performance measure; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 30 count | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning protocol development, tasks solved at least once in ten attempts |
| Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (protocol-development tasks solved in every one of ten attempts, out of 50; a coverage count under repeated sampling, not a single-attempt performance measure; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 2 count | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning protocol development, tasks solved in every one of ten attempts |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort | Success rate (aggregate single-attempt score over all 65 tasks, task-weighted 50/65 protocol development and 15/65 construct design; mid reasoning tier, the middle of this system's three settings) | 20.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Opus 5.5 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort | Success rate (construct-design pass rate at a single attempt, pass at a final score of at least 0.9, deterministic grading on five tasks and deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score on ten; mid reasoning tier, the middle of this system's three settings) | 34.7 percent | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15) | Claude Opus 5.5 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass rate at a single attempt (pass@1), simulator-graded and binary per attempt; mid reasoning tier, the middle of this system's three settings) | 15.6 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Opus 5.5 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort | Success rate (aggregate single-attempt score over all 65 tasks, task-weighted 50/65 protocol development and 15/65 construct design; low reasoning tier, the lowest of this system's three settings) | 12.3 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Opus 5.5 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort | Success rate (construct-design pass rate at a single attempt, pass at a final score of at least 0.9, deterministic grading on five tasks and deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score on ten; low reasoning tier, the lowest of this system's three settings) | 29.3 percent | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15) | Claude Opus 5.5 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass rate at a single attempt (pass@1), simulator-graded and binary per attempt; low reasoning tier, the lowest of this system's three settings) | 7.2 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Opus 5.5 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (aggregate single-attempt score over all 65 tasks, task-weighted 50/65 protocol development and 15/65 construct design; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 20.5 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Opus 5.5 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (construct-design pass rate at a single attempt, pass at a final score of at least 0.9, deterministic grading on five tasks and deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score on ten; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 25.3 percent | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15) | Claude Opus 5.5 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Success rate (protocol-development pass rate at a single attempt (pass@1), simulator-graded and binary per attempt; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 19.0 percent | BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50) | Claude Opus 5.5 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 1/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: AG/AP1 chimera plasmid |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Alkaloid-pathway GoldenBraid set |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Detector choice from antibody data |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Dual-luciferase frame panel |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 3/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: GFP into EcoFlex vector |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin intermediate construct |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin two-chain constructs |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 5/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Matched promoter panel |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 1/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Minimal-edit recoding |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 3/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: MPRA construct rebuild |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic multiplied by a GPT-6 Astra rubric score, so the outcome depends on the judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Prime-assembly donor family |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 5/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Reporter choice from data |
| Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort | Count (construct-design attempts passed out of 5 on one task at top reasoning effort, pass at a final score of at least 0.9; grading deterministic only, no model judge; top reasoning tier, the highest of this system's three settings) | 0/5 count | BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5) | Claude Opus 5.5 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Sodium-channel promoter repair |
Claims
Statements this source supports, each with where in the source it was checked.
- All systems on the ten rubric-judged tasks: Attempts on judged tasks: Judged task attempts total 400 (Table F3, row 'Total', column 'Attempts on judged tasks')
- All systems on the ten rubric-judged tasks: Judge score below 0.9: Judge score below threshold total 34 (Table F3, row 'Total', column 'Judge score below 0.9')
- All systems on the ten rubric-judged tasks: Passed deterministic checks: Passed deterministic checks total 142 (Table F3, row 'Total', column 'Passed deterministic checks')
- BenchBench-Cloning: access: Access The construct-design tasks, graders and reference solutions are said in footnote 1 (page 3) to be available at https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning. That URL returned HTTP 404 from both the web page and the GitHub API on 2026-11-06 at 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z, a repository search for 'benchbench-cloning' returned no results, and the repository is absent from benchling's public repositories. No code or data artifact was retrieved. (Footnote 1 (page 3); GitHub web page and API checked 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z)
- BenchBench-Cloning: attempt budget: Attempt budget Two hours per attempt, in a Modal sandbox with two vCPUs and 6 GiB of memory and network access restricted to the model provider, orchestrated with Harbor (Section 3.3; Appendix B)
- BenchBench-Cloning: attempts per task: Attempts per task Ten per protocol-development task and five per construct-design task, at every reasoning setting (Section 3.3; Appendix B)
- BenchBench-Cloning: data release: Data release Not offered for download: footnote 1 names only the construct-design tasks, graders and reference solutions (Footnote 1 (page 3))
- BenchBench-Cloning: failure mode: Failure mode GPT-6 Astra and GPT-6.1 Sol built an eight-construct factorial panel in every attempt and so failed the smallest-panel check, while most other systems submitted the four-construct panel and passed (Section 5.3; Table G2)
- BenchBench-Cloning: failure mode: Failure mode No system ever repaired the second of the two constructs the task requires (Section 5.3; Table G2)
- BenchBench-Cloning: judge model: Judge model GPT-6 Astra (Section 3.3)
- BenchBench-Cloning: licence: Licence The preprint is licensed CC BY 4.0 (arXiv abstract page). That covers the article text, not the benchmark code or task data, whose licence is unverified because the linked repository could not be retrieved. (arXiv abstract page licence link; footnote 1 (page 3))
- BenchBench-Cloning: measurement scope: Measurement scope Simulated and retrospectively graded planning only; no measured laboratory success (Section 6.2)
- BenchBench-Cloning: model graded task count: Model graded task count 10 of 15 (Section 3.2; Appendix A, Table A1 column 'Grading')
- BenchBench-Cloning: pass threshold: Pass threshold Final score of at least 0.9 (Section 3.4; Appendix A)
- BenchBench-Cloning: product length range: Product length range 2.8 kb to 15.2 kb, median 5.4 kb (Section 3.1)
- BenchBench-Cloning: ranking stability: Ranking stability System ranking is not stable in k: Claude Opus 5.5 beats GPT-6.1 Sol at a single attempt and loses to it at ten (Section 4.2)
- BenchBench-Cloning: saturation: Saturation Not saturated within ten attempts: the strongest system leaves 14 of the 50 protocol-development tasks unsolved (Abstract; Section 4.2; Section 7)
- BenchBench-Cloning: second judge model: Second judge model Claude Mythos 5.1 (Section 3.3; Appendix C)
- BenchBench-Cloning: starting materials per task: Starting materials per task Up to eight starting plasmid constructs (Section 3.1)
- BenchBench-Cloning: supported operations: Supported operations 42 (Section 2; Section 3.1)
- BenchBench-Cloning: systems evaluated: Systems evaluated 8 (Section 3.3; Table B1; Table 2)
- BenchBench-Cloning: task count: Task count 15 (Abstract; Section 3.2; Table A1; Table G2)
- BenchBench-Cloning: task count: Task count 50 (Abstract; Section 3.1; Table 1, row 'Total', column 'Tasks')
- BenchBench-Cloning: task count: Task count 65 (Abstract; Section 1; Section 3)
- BenchBench-Cloning: tasks supplying experimental records: Tasks supplying experimental records 6 of 15 (Section 3.2; Table A1 column 'Experimental records supplied')
Models, benchmarks and other records
Models (8)
Methods (5)
Configurations (24)
- Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort
- Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort
- Claude Mythos 5.1 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort
- Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, high reasoning effort
- Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, low reasoning effort
- Claude Opus 5.5 in Claude Code 2.1.289, max reasoning effort
- Gemini 3.8 Flash in Gemini CLI 0.63.0, high reasoning effort
- Gemini 3.8 Flash in Gemini CLI 0.63.0, low reasoning effort
- Gemini 3.8 Flash in Gemini CLI 0.63.0, medium reasoning effort
- Gemini 4 Argon in Gemini CLI 0.63.0, high reasoning effort
- Gemini 4 Argon in Gemini CLI 0.63.0, low reasoning effort
- Gemini 4 Argon in Gemini CLI 0.63.0, medium reasoning effort
- GPT-6 Astra in Codex CLI 0.156.1, high reasoning effort
- GPT-6 Astra in Codex CLI 0.156.1, low reasoning effort
- GPT-6 Astra in Codex CLI 0.156.1, max reasoning effort
- GPT-6.1 Sol in Codex CLI 0.156.1, high reasoning effort
- GPT-6.1 Sol in Codex CLI 0.156.1, low reasoning effort
- GPT-6.1 Sol in Codex CLI 0.156.1, max reasoning effort
- Grok 4.7 in Grok Build 1.0.46, high reasoning effort
- Grok 4.7 in Grok Build 1.0.46, low reasoning effort
- Grok 4.7 in Grok Build 1.0.46, xhigh reasoning effort
- Kimi K3 in Pi 1.0.3, high reasoning effort
- Kimi K3 in Pi 1.0.3, low reasoning effort
- Kimi K3 in Pi 1.0.3, medium reasoning effort
Benchmarks (3)
Tasks (15)
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: AG/AP1 chimera plasmid
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Alkaloid-pathway GoldenBraid set
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Detector choice from antibody data
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Dual-luciferase frame panel
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: GFP into EcoFlex vector
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin intermediate construct
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin two-chain constructs
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Matched promoter panel
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Minimal-edit recoding
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: MPRA construct rebuild
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Prime-assembly donor family
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Reporter choice from data
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Sodium-channel promoter repair
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Synthetic-chromosome locus edit
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Tus/TerB HEK293 constructs
Protocols (9)
- BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score over all 65 tasks
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design, per task: attempts passed out of 5, deterministic grading only
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design, per task: attempts passed out of 5, deterministic grading with a rubric model judge
- BenchBench-Cloning construct design: single-attempt pass rate over 15 tasks
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol development: pass@5 over 50 tasks
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol development: pass@10 over 50 tasks
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol development: single-attempt pass rate over 50 tasks
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol development: tasks solved at least once in the ten recorded attempts, out of 50
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol development: tasks solved in every one of the ten recorded attempts, out of 50
Evaluators (4)
Datasets (1)
Dataset subsets (13)
- BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks (15)
- BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks graded deterministically only (5)
- BenchBench-Cloning construct-design tasks with a rubric model judge (10)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks (50)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Backbone end chemistry (6)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Counterselection (4)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Expression vectors and (2)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: GC-rich templates (4)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Golden Gate / MoClo (5)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Homology-directed and (7)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Methylation state (11)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Recombination, CRISPR (4)
- BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development tasks: Repeats and tandem (7)
Evaluations (224)
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at high effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at low effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning aggregate score
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning construct-design pass rate
- Claude Mythos 5.1 at max effort on BenchBench-Cloning protocol-development pass rate
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: AG/AP1 chimera plasmid
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Alkaloid-pathway GoldenBraid set
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Detector choice from antibody data
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Dual-luciferase frame panel
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: GFP into EcoFlex vector
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin intermediate construct
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Insulin two-chain constructs
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Matched promoter panel
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Minimal-edit recoding
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: MPRA construct rebuild
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Prime-assembly donor family
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Reporter choice from data
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Sodium-channel promoter repair
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Synthetic-chromosome locus edit
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning construct design: Tus/TerB HEK293 constructs
- Claude Mythos 5.1 on BenchBench-Cloning protocol development, pass@5
Sources (2)
Evidence
Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.
Evidence table
Inspect claims, sources and review details
Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.
One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.
37 evidence rows matching the loaded filters
| Property and statement | Original source and location | Review and provenance |
|---|---|---|
| Access note The construct-design tasks, graders and reference solutions are said in footnote 1 (page 3) to be available at https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning. That URL returned HTTP 404 from both the web page and the GitHub API on 2026-11-06 at 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z, a repository search for 'benchbench-cloning' returned no results, and the repository is absent from benchling's public repositories. No code or data artifact was retrieved. Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Archive member artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Archive note The gzipped pdftotext -layout text layer of the pinned PDF is kept in the batch folder because every stored value was parsed from it. The PDF itself is refetchable at the versioned URL and is not archived; two downloads on 2026-11-06 were byte-identical. Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Archive sha256 c52ec41e171a81180ed0b9110e6ff26999740a73d7ecf2ab1fd600591357a616 Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Article licence CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Artifact SHA-256 6f5044b1bbbd81ad86b23cb536e2cae6428e0d9126f11546041355518febdc39 Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Code url https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
Evidence concerns1 values
| BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
| Licence CC BY 4.0 Source metadata | BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
Limitations6 values
| BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) No field-specific location recorded Version: arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026 | catalogued No individual claim review recorded Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Archive member: artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz |
Sources and history
Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Record review: source checked
Preprint introducing BenchBench-Cloning, a 65-task molecular cloning benchmark, and reporting eight language-model agent systems scored on it at three reasoning settings each.
1 source record and release history
- BenchBench-Cloning: Evaluating Molecular Cloning Design and Protocol Development (arXiv:2610.33355v1) · Original source · arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026
Technical metadata and extraction receipts
Stable ID: benchbench-cloning-20261106-source-arxiv-v1
- areas
- dna-genomes
- contexts
- research
- access note
- The construct-design tasks, graders and reference solutions are said in footnote 1 (page 3) to be available at https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning. That URL returned HTTP 404 from both the web page and the GitHub API on 2026-11-06 at 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z, a repository search for 'benchbench-cloning' returned no results, and the repository is absent from benchling's public repositories. No code or data artifact was retrieved.
- archive member
- artifacts/arxiv-2610.33355v1.layout.txt.gz
- archive note
- The gzipped pdftotext -layout text layer of the pinned PDF is kept in the batch folder because every stored value was parsed from it. The PDF itself is refetchable at the versioned URL and is not archived; two downloads on 2026-11-06 were byte-identical.
- archive sha256
- c52ec41e171a81180ed0b9110e6ff26999740a73d7ecf2ab1fd600591357a616
- article licence
- CC BY 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/)
- artifact sha256
- 6f5044b1bbbd81ad86b23cb536e2cae6428e0d9126f11546041355518febdc39
- code url
- https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning
- evidence concerns
- applies to: benchbench-cloning-20261106-result-gemini-4-argon-low-construct-design; artifact sha256: 6f5044b1bbbd81ad86b23cb536e2cae6428e0d9126f11546041355518febdc39; message: Table D2's construct-design rate for Gemini 4 Argon at low effort, 31.9%, cannot be a mean of binary outcomes over the stated 15 tasks times 5 attempts: no integer numerator over 75 falls in its rounding window [23.8875, 23.9625], while all 23 other printed construct rates do. Its printed 95% interval [10.7, 52.0] is also byte-identical to the same system's top-effort interval. The two signals together indicate a transcription fault in the paper rather than a measured value, and the paper prints nothing that resolves it: the lane's aggregate is 15.8 under either 31.9 or 32.0, and Table G2's per-task solves are top-effort only. The printed value is kept as published and this entry withholds it from automatic comparison; the lane's other results are not covered.; review method: independent-cell-check; reviewed at: 2026-11-06T00:00:00Z; source id: benchbench-cloning-20261106-source-arxiv-v1; source locator: Table D2, row 'Gemini 4 Argon' tier 'low' effort 'low', column 'Construct design % [95% CI]'
- licence
- CC BY 4.0
- limitations
- Preprint, not peer reviewed. The benchmark is published by Benchling with DNAForge, and the authors both built the benchmark and ran every system on it.; Scores come from a cloning simulator and retrospective graders, not from constructs built at the bench; the authors state the simulator cannot capture every source of variation in reagents, handling, growth or reaction outcomes (Section 6.2).; Ten of the fifteen construct-design tasks are graded in part by GPT-6 Astra as a rubric judge, which is also one of the eight evaluated systems; the authors record occasional grading inconsistency as a limitation (Section 6.2).; The simulator reports only the first blocking error, so the failure categories in Tables E1 and E2 do not establish whether later steps would have succeeded (Section 6.2).; Single-turn: the authors state the format does not reflect the multi-turn way scientists work with a model (Section 6.2).; The construct-design tasks, graders and reference solutions are said in footnote 1 (page 3) to be available at https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning. That URL returned HTTP 404 from both the web page and the GitHub API on 2026-11-06 at 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z, a repository search for 'benchbench-cloning' returned no results, and the repository is absent from benchling's public repositories. No code or data artifact was retrieved.
- media type
- application/pdf
- missing metadata
- code licence: note: The construct-design tasks, graders and reference solutions are said in footnote 1 (page 3) to be available at https://github.com/benchling/benchbench-cloning. That URL returned HTTP 404 from both the web page and the GitHub API on 2026-11-06 at 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z, a repository search for 'benchbench-cloning' returned no results, and the repository is absent from benchling's public repositories. No code or data artifact was retrieved.; reason: unavailable; doi: note: The arXiv abstract page serves no citation_doi for this preprint.; reason: unavailable
- publication status
- preprint
- retrieved at
- 2026-11-06T11:51:23Z
- review
- artifact sha256: 6f5044b1bbbd81ad86b23cb536e2cae6428e0d9126f11546041355518febdc39; date: 2026-11-06; method: source-hash-verification; pdf-text-parse; note: Downloaded twice on 2026-11-06 with identical bytes. The pinned PDF hashes to the recorded SHA-256 and its text layer to the recorded archive hash.; retrieval url: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2610.33355v1; reviewer: claude; reviewer note: Claude (Opus 5) extraction agent. Extraction only: no independent review is claimed, and a different agent reviews this batch.
- source locator
- Whole preprint, 19 pages; Tables 1, 2, A1, B1, C1, D1, D2, E1, E2, F1, F3, G1, G2
- url
- https://arxiv.org/pdf/2610.33355v1
- venue
- arXiv (cs.AI)
- version
- arXiv v1, dated 23 October 2026
- year
- 2026
Related records
- companion of: arXiv abstract page for 2610.33355
- companion of: How good is AI at molecular biology? (Benchling announcement)