| Comparison: adaptation trained on the cohort following the published DeepRVAT procedure Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.adaptation Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: aggregation Average over three runs with different random seeds Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.aggregation Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: budget Not reported Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | missing or unspecified No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.budget Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: dataset version UK Biobank whole-exome sequencing, 161,822 unrelated individuals of European ancestry Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.dataset_version Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: inputs Variant annotations aggregated per gene Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.inputs Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: metric implementation Family-wise error rate below 0.05 Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.metric_implementation Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: population 161,822 unrelated individuals of European ancestry Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.population Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: protocol id gpn-star-20261116-protocol-rvat-significant-genes Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.protocol_id Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
| Comparison: split 34 quantitative traits; variants with minor allele frequency below 0.1% Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.comparison.split Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|
Limitations2 values- Author-reported.
- The paper's 'on average across runs' is stated for the comparison; it does not separately say whether the original DeepRVAT counts are means over three runs.
Context-only references | Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) Original source ↗ Results, rare variant association testing paragraph (PDF page 5) Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09 Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded author reported Audit detailsField: attributes.limitations Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte. Inspected artifact |
|---|