rewirebio.iobenchmarks
Evaluation

PhastCons (M) on gnomAD rare versus common enrichment (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)

Published comparison transcribed from the pinned source; not reproduced.

Evaluation results

1 evaluation · 1 result. Different protocols are not a single leaderboard.

Filter evaluations

Applied filters: All linked evaluations

Exact evaluated configurations and original reported results
Tested configurationProtocol and datasetFindingEvidence and details
Configuration: PhastCons (M) (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)Protocol: gnomAD rare versus common enrichment in the deleterious tail, odds ratio (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)
Dataset: gnomAD rare versus common variants, consequence-balanced (GPN-Star paper)
1.9 Odds ratio (genome-wide enrichment of singletons over common variants in the deleterious tail at the threshold giving 30 false discoveries)
unitless · higher

Uncertainty: Not reported by the source: No error bar or interval is printed for the panel b labels

Coverage: Not reported scored / Not reported eligible

Author-reported evaluation · Source checked
Methods, coverage and source

PhastCons (M) on gnomAD rare versus common enrichment (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)

gpn-star-20261116-protocol-gnomad-rare-vs-common-odds-ratio

Aggregation: Not reported

Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature) · Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)', printed bar label (PDF page 7)

Source checking is not independent reproduction. Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb.

Research readiness

0 of 4 readiness checks met. These checks assess whether the evidence supports a reproducible investigation; a source-checked score alone does not meet them.

Readiness checks, gaps and artifacts

Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Evidence verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Replay metrics

Exact outcomes, predictions, identifiers and evaluator are connected.

Missing or unresolved evidence

  • No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
  • File checksums match the recorded files: not yet verified
  • Predictions are matched to the right samples: not yet verified
  • Score meaning and direction are confirmed: not yet verified
  • Metrics are recomputed from the saved predictions: not yet verified

Verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Investigate discrepancies

Replay evidence includes annotations and an assessment of dependence. Unknown independence permits descriptive analysis only.

Missing or unresolved evidence

  • No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
  • File checksums match the recorded files: not yet verified
  • Predictions are matched to the right samples: not yet verified
  • Score meaning and direction are confirmed: not yet verified
  • Metrics are recomputed from the saved predictions: not yet verified
  • Sample annotations are recorded: not yet verified
  • Dependence between samples is assessed: not yet verified

Verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Run locally

A pinned recipe describes the inputs, environment and resource requirements.

Missing or unresolved evidence

  • No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
  • File checksums match the recorded files: not yet verified
  • Predictions are matched to the right samples: not yet verified
  • Score meaning and direction are confirmed: not yet verified
  • A pinned run recipe exists: not yet verified
  • Compute requirements are estimated: not yet verified

Verified: Not verified

Evidence incomplete

Validate independently

Separate data and exposure records support an independent test.

Missing or unresolved evidence

  • No verified artifact manifest is linked to this exact record.
  • File checksums match the recorded files: not yet verified
  • Predictions are matched to the right samples: not yet verified
  • Score meaning and direction are confirmed: not yet verified
  • Independent validation data exist: not yet verified
  • Overlap with training data is checked: not yet verified

Verified: Not verified

Readiness describes the evidence in this release. Availability on your computer is checked separately when an investigation runs. Existing data exposure can prevent independent validation even when files are available.

Artifacts and reproduction

No verified artifact manifest is connected to this record yet. The gaps above identify what is needed before analysis can begin.

Evaluation procedure

gnomAD rare versus common enrichment in the deleterious tail, odds ratio (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)

Configuration
PhastCons (M) (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)
Protocol
gnomAD rare versus common enrichment in the deleterious tail, odds ratio (GPN-Star Fig. 4b)
Dataset
gnomAD rare versus common variants, consequence-balanced (GPN-Star paper)
origin
Author-reported evaluation
configuration
Nature version of record (2026-09-09)
adaptation
zero-shot
aggregation
Genome-wide odds ratio at the threshold giving 30 false discoveries
budget
Not reported
dataset version
gnomAD v3.1.2
inputs
Per-variant deleteriousness or constraint score
metric implementation
Not reported
population
5.5 million rare versus 5.6 million common variants
protocol id
gpn-star-20261116-protocol-gnomad-rare-vs-common-odds-ratio
split
Genome-wide; GPN-Star's held-out test chromosome is chromosome 22

Metadata review: source checked. Unreported conditions prevent automatic comparisons.

Reproduction

Split
Genome-wide; GPN-Star's held-out test chromosome is chromosome 22
Adaptation
zero-shot
Scoring implementation
Not reported

No execution recipe has been verified for this exact configuration and evaluation. A benchmark's general instructions may use different inputs, splits or model settings.

Reproducing this published result requires matching its model configuration, data, split and scorer. Source checking or a successful smoke test does not establish score reproduction.

Evidence

Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.

Evidence table

Inspect claims, sources and review details

Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.

One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.

38 evidence rows matching the loaded filters

Claims, original sources and review scope · Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb
Property and statementOriginal source and locationReview and provenance
Comparison: adaptation
zero-shot
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature)

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.adaptation

Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: adaptation
zero-shot
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026 GPN-Star, Nature Supplementary Information

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Supplementary Information PDF (MOESM1) of the version of record, 57 pages
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:12:33Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.adaptation

Source artifact SHA-256: 3f7e8f71710bb63ec5ff032e697b6ef85f0d6d74411a31865fed73a757c7fc9e

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the supplementary PDF as downloaded; a second download in the same session reproduced the hash.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: aggregation
Genome-wide odds ratio at the threshold giving 30 false discoveries
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature)

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.aggregation

Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: aggregation
Genome-wide odds ratio at the threshold giving 30 false discoveries
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026 GPN-Star, Nature Supplementary Information

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Supplementary Information PDF (MOESM1) of the version of record, 57 pages
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:12:33Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.aggregation

Source artifact SHA-256: 3f7e8f71710bb63ec5ff032e697b6ef85f0d6d74411a31865fed73a757c7fc9e

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the supplementary PDF as downloaded; a second download in the same session reproduced the hash.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: budget
Not reported
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature)

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z

missing or unspecified

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.budget

Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: budget
Not reported
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026 GPN-Star, Nature Supplementary Information

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Supplementary Information PDF (MOESM1) of the version of record, 57 pages
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:12:33Z

missing or unspecified

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.budget

Source artifact SHA-256: 3f7e8f71710bb63ec5ff032e697b6ef85f0d6d74411a31865fed73a757c7fc9e

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the supplementary PDF as downloaded; a second download in the same session reproduced the hash.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: dataset version
gnomAD v3.1.2
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature)

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.dataset_version

Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: dataset version
gnomAD v3.1.2
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026 GPN-Star, Nature Supplementary Information

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Supplementary Information PDF (MOESM1) of the version of record, 57 pages
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:12:33Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.dataset_version

Source artifact SHA-256: 3f7e8f71710bb63ec5ff032e697b6ef85f0d6d74411a31865fed73a757c7fc9e

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the supplementary PDF as downloaded; a second download in the same session reproduced the hash.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: inputs
Per-variant deleteriousness or constraint score
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026, Predicting genome-wide functional constraints with GPN-Star (Nature)

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Version of record: Nature 659, 141-150 (5 November 2026); received 2025-09-10, accepted 2026-08-07, published online 2026-09-09
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:11:46Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.inputs

Source artifact SHA-256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the 26-page publisher PDF as downloaded. A second download in the same session reproduced the hash byte for byte.

Inspected artifact

Comparison: inputs
Per-variant deleteriousness or constraint score
Context-only references
Ye et al. 2026 GPN-Star, Nature Supplementary Information

Original source ↗

Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)

Shared locator for this statement’s cited sources; not a separate locator for each citation.

Version: Supplementary Information PDF (MOESM1) of the version of record, 57 pages
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:12:33Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

author reported

Audit details

Field: attributes.comparison.inputs

Source artifact SHA-256: 3f7e8f71710bb63ec5ff032e697b6ef85f0d6d74411a31865fed73a757c7fc9e

Hash scope: SHA-256 of the supplementary PDF as downloaded; a second download in the same session reproduced the hash.

Inspected artifact

How to read the evidence

Sources and history

Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Record review: source checked

2 source records and release historyDownload this release (gzip)
Technical metadata and extraction receipts

Stable ID: gpn-star-20261116-eval-fig4b-phastcons-m

areas
dna-genomes
contexts
research
comparison
adaptation: zero-shot; aggregation: Genome-wide odds ratio at the threshold giving 30 false discoveries; budget: Not reported; dataset version: gnomAD v3.1.2; inputs: Per-variant deleteriousness or constraint score; metric implementation: Not reported; population: 5.5 million rare versus 5.6 million common variants; protocol id: gpn-star-20261116-protocol-gnomad-rare-vs-common-odds-ratio; split: Genome-wide; GPN-Star's held-out test chromosome is chromosome 22
limitations
Author-reported.; Value read from a printed bar label; no uncertainty is printed.
missing metadata
comparison.budget: reason: unreported; comparison.metric implementation: reason: unreported
origin
author_reported
protocol
gpn-star-20261116-protocol-gnomad-rare-vs-common-odds-ratio
review
artifact sha256: d7dfe801bad2a0a23478753147af2320bc31c8b37ee50d66f1a1af8385e9005d; method: transcription; pdf-text-parse; source-hash-verification; method note: Independent review pass of 2026-11-16. All four pinned artifacts were re-retrieved. The Nature article PDF, the Supplementary Information PDF and the Hugging Face collection API JSON each hashed to the value on their source record. The bioRxiv PDF did not and cannot: two downloads minutes apart gave b3e4d729d3363c16fb6b6cb99e4e18ffadb01b48614dba910480fb96f42b3d73 and 47f87f72baf93793177d3e40f70f43f03ac5d3050bbc5244f655e92041c7db4a, differing from each other in 34 bytes, all of them download-time stamps (XMP ModifyDate and MetadataDate, the xmpMM DocumentID and InstanceID, the document /ModDate and the second element of the trailer /ID); the page count, the CreationDate of 2025-09-21 and the pdftotext -layout text layer are identical across downloads. No value in this batch comes from the preprint. npm run batch -- check-values reproduced the extractor's figures exactly: 12 in_cell, 44 in_row, 16 locator_not_parsed, no not_in_row, no wrong_column and no overclaimed_in_row (value-check.tsv). All 72 results were then re-read by review/check_values_independent.py, written for this pass and importing nothing from extract/build.py. Supplementary Table 3 is printed rotated, so that script reads the page's word bounding boxes rather than a text dump: it recovers the seven column bands from the header words' y extents, pairing each 'Finemapped' header with whichever of 'coding' and 'non-coding' overlaps it, clusters the body words into eight row bands by x centre, and places every numeric token in the cell whose column centre is nearest, rejecting any token that is more than 45 per cent of a column pitch from its nearest column or less than 25 per cent of a pitch clear of the runner-up. Column order is therefore a measured property of the page and not an assumption, which is the check extract/build.py could not make: it asserted the column order positionally. Results are matched to cells through each source_locator's text, not through record IDs. Fig. 4b's 12 bar labels were required to be the first number printed after their series label on the same line, and the four rare variant counts were matched against the two sentences that print them, with the capture position fixing which count belongs to DeepRVAT with GPN-Star annotations and which to the original method. Result: 68 in cell, 4 in sentence, 0 failures (review/value-check-independent.tsv). Two negative controls confirm the checker is a cell check and not a row check: exchanging two ClinVar values between rows and moving a Fig. 4b label onto another series both fail (review/control-swap.tsv), and shifting a value into a neighbouring column of its own row fails and names the column that actually holds it, including across the Finemapped coding / OMIM and Finemapped coding / Finemapped non-coding boundaries (review/control-shift.tsv). Independently of both scripts, all 56 cells of Supplementary Table 3 and all 12 Fig. 4b labels were transcribed by hand from the pages rendered at 190 dpi with pdftoppm, into review/manual-transcription.tsv, and compared by review/cmp_manual.py: 68 values, 0 problems. That hand pass is what settles the column assignment the repository checker could only place at row level. The 12 descriptive claims were read against the pinned PDFs and the collection JSON.; note: The system, assessment and data links and the comparison fields were checked against the source text the locator names; every null comparison field was confirmed unstated there.; retrieval url: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-026-11005-5.pdf; reviewed at: 2026-11-16T01:30:00Z; reviewer: claude; reviewer note: Claude review agent (independent of the extractor); no human review claimed. Values were checked against the pinned artifacts; nothing was reproduced and no value was recomputed.
source locator
Fig. 4b, row 'PhastCons (M)' (PDF page 7)
version
Nature version of record (2026-09-09)
Related records

Suggest a correction