Maximum mean discrepancy (k-mer spectrum MMD, under conditions and a reference set size the replication could not recover) of Random homolog pairing ceiling, published values on The six evaluation datasets behind EvoFlows' published figures
0.61 Maximum mean discrepancy (k-mer spectrum MMD, under conditions and a reference set size the replication could not recover)
Methods
- Tested configuration
- Random homolog pairing ceiling, published values
- Protocol
- EvoFlows published values, two families: MMD
- Dataset
- The six evaluation datasets behind EvoFlows' published figures
- Procedure
- The conditions under which the EvoFlows paper produced these values, which the replication states it could not recover.
- Evaluation
- random pairing on HER2-VH, MMD, EvoFlows published values
- Coverage
- Not reported scored / Not reported eligible
- Uncertainty
- Not reported by the source: The table prints a single value with no interval.
- Evidence
- Author-reported evaluation · source checkedWhen Edit Flows are Edit Jumps: replicating Edit Flows and EvoFlows (arXiv v1) · Table 1, lower block, row "random pairing", column "MMD", sub-column "HER2"
A source-checked result verifies the numerical transcription, not every model or protocol detail. Evaluation metadata: source checked. Source checked does not mean independently reproduced.
Reproduction
- Split
- Not reported
- Adaptation
- Per-family retraining, which the original approach requires
- Scoring implementation
- Not reported
No execution recipe has been verified for this exact configuration and evaluation. A benchmark's general instructions may use different inputs, splits or model settings.
Reproducing this published result requires matching its model configuration, data, split and scorer. Source checking or a successful smoke test does not establish score reproduction.
Evidence
Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.
Evidence table
Inspect claims, sources and review details
Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.
One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.
1 evidence row matching the loaded filters
| Property and statement | Original source and location | Review and provenance |
|---|---|---|
| Reported result 0.61 Individual claims | When Edit Flows are Edit Jumps: replicating Edit Flows and EvoFlows (arXiv v1) Table 1, lower block, row "random pairing", column "MMD", sub-column "HER2" Version: arXiv:2609.18745v1, 16 September 2026 | source checked ["independent-cell-check","deterministic-table-parse","pdf-text-parse","source-hash-verification"] · 2026-11-16T01:30:00Z author reported Source has a recorded evidence concern. Consult its source page before using the claim. Audit detailsRe-read from the pinned PDF's text layer and from the arXiv HTML rendering. Table 1's lower block runs its columns together in the text layer, so the PDF model assigns this value by its ordinal position in the printed row and the HTML model by the table markup; both place it in the column, sub-column and block the locator names. Exchanging the upper and lower blocks for one row label is rejected by both models. Field: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record Extraction artifact SHA-256: |
Sources and history
Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Record review: source checked
1 source record and release history
- When Edit Flows are Edit Jumps: replicating Edit Flows and EvoFlows (arXiv v1) · Original source · arXiv:2609.18745v1, 16 September 2026
Technical metadata and extraction receipts
Stable ID: editjumps-20261115-result-published-spectrum-mmd-random-pairing-her2vh
- areas
- protein-function; proteins-complexes
- contexts
- research
- limitations
- Computational distribution comparison only. The value measures how similar generated sequences are to a reference set of natural sequences; it is not a measured binding affinity, specificity, stability or retained function.; Scores depend on the size of the reference set. Expanding the reference alignment from 200 to 800 homologs alters the normalised spectrum MMD ratio by 50% on Ty1 and 26% on HER2-VH, which the paper states is large enough to invert method rankings, so the ordering of methods is not stable across reference-set sizes.; The paper states that its computed values and the published EvoFlows values are not comparable and that it could not recover the original experimental conditions from the EvoFlows paper. Table 1's caption adds that the two blocks are not comparable and that each row compares only against its own block's floor and ceiling.; Reference set size, split, templates, seeds and metric implementation behind these published values could not be recovered from the EvoFlows paper, so the comparison fields are unknown.
- metric
- maximum-mean-discrepancy
- metric direction
- lower
- metric qualifier
- k-mer spectrum MMD, under conditions and a reference set size the replication could not recover
- missing metadata
- uncertainty: note: The table prints a single value with no interval.; reason: unreported
- numeric value
- 0.61
- printed value
- 0.61
- review
- artifact sha256: 4211d8ef46c55efe8d89ba4ee6c0b4e57cca1e78d0856e9cdfbde37046a7f4e1; method: independent-cell-check; deterministic-table-parse; pdf-text-parse; source-hash-verification; method note: Independent review pass. Every pinned artifact was re-downloaded from the URL in its source record and its SHA-256 recomputed: all nine match. The arXiv PDF's text layer was regenerated with pdftotext -layout from poppler 26.08.0 and matches the hash notes.md records. npm run batch -- check-values over the whole batch reproduced the extractor's figures exactly (8 in_cell, 164 in_row, 3 locator_not_parsed, no wrong_column and no overclaimed_in_row). Because 164 results sit at in_row only, column assignment was then checked separately by review/column_check.py, written for this pass and using neither extract/tables.py nor extract/check_tables.py. It builds two independent column models: the PDF text layer, where Tables 2 and 4 are assigned by clustering printed field right edges and Table 1 by ordinal position within the row, and the arXiv HTML rendering parsed as a cell grid from the table markup. The two models agree on every cell, and all 172 table-located results match their locator's column and block in both. Four negative controls, two columns exchanged within a row, a row shifted one column left, a Ty1 and HER2 sub-column exchanged, and the Table 1 upper and lower blocks exchanged for one row label, are rejected by both models.; note: Re-read from the pinned PDF's text layer and from the arXiv HTML rendering. Table 1's lower block runs its columns together in the text layer, so the PDF model assigns this value by its ordinal position in the printed row and the HTML model by the table markup; both place it in the column, sub-column and block the locator names. Exchanging the upper and lower blocks for one row label is rejected by both models.; retrieval url: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2609.18745v1; reviewed at: 2026-11-16T01:30:00Z; reviewer: claude; reviewer note: Claude (Opus 5) review agent for issue #244, independent of the extraction agent; no human review claimed. All nine pinned artifacts were re-retrieved and their SHA-256 re-computed; no value was reproduced and no model was run.
- source locator
- Table 1, lower block, row "random pairing", column "MMD", sub-column "HER2"
- unit
- unitless