rewirebio.iobenchmarks
Evidence claim

The only comparator figure the GPN paper prints for Figure 6D

Comparator bound of GWAS hit enrichment in the lowest 1% of scores, AraGWAS permutation threshold

"while less than 7.5-fold enrichment was observed for other methods (Fig. 6D)". The other methods are phyloP x LD, phastCons x LD, abs(phyloP) x LD and LD Score. Figure 6D prints no per-method value in its text layer, so none is recorded.

The bound the paper states for the other methods in its GWAS enrichment comparison, recorded because the per-method values are only in the bar chart.

Evidence

Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.

Evidence table

Inspect claims, sources and review details

Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.

One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.

6 evidence rows matching the loaded filters

Claims, original sources and review scope · Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb
Property and statementOriginal source and locationReview and provenance
Claimed field
comparator_bound
Context-only references
DNA language models are powerful predictors of genome-wide variant effects (PNAS 2023)

Original source ↗

Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined

Version: PNAS 120(44) e2311219120, published 26 October 2023; Europe PMC full text JATS XML of PMC10622914
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:29:00Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.field

Source artifact SHA-256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: JATS XML

Source location
Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined
Context-only references
DNA language models are powerful predictors of genome-wide variant effects (PNAS 2023)

Original source ↗

Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined

Version: PNAS 120(44) e2311219120, published 26 October 2023; Europe PMC full text JATS XML of PMC10622914
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:29:00Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.source_locator

Source artifact SHA-256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: JATS XML

Claimed value
"while less than 7.5-fold enrichment was observed for other methods (Fig. 6D)". The other methods are phyloP x LD, phastCons x LD, abs(phyloP) x LD and LD Score. Figure 6D prints no per-method value in its text layer, so none is recorded.
Context-only references
DNA language models are powerful predictors of genome-wide variant effects (PNAS 2023)

Original source ↗

Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined

Version: PNAS 120(44) e2311219120, published 26 October 2023; Europe PMC full text JATS XML of PMC10622914
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:29:00Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: attributes.value

Source artifact SHA-256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: JATS XML

Description
The bound the paper states for the other methods in its GWAS enrichment comparison, recorded because the per-method values are only in the bar chart.
Context-only references
DNA language models are powerful predictors of genome-wide variant effects (PNAS 2023)

Original source ↗

Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined

Version: PNAS 120(44) e2311219120, published 26 October 2023; Europe PMC full text JATS XML of PMC10622914
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:29:00Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: description

Source artifact SHA-256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: JATS XML

Relationship: subject
gpn-paper-20261116-protocol-gwas-hit-odds-ratio
Context-only references
DNA language models are powerful predictors of genome-wide variant effects (PNAS 2023)

Original source ↗

Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined

Version: PNAS 120(44) e2311219120, published 26 October 2023; Europe PMC full text JATS XML of PMC10622914
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:29:00Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: links:subject:gpn-paper-20261116-protocol-gwas-hit-odds-ratio

Source artifact SHA-256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: JATS XML

Name
The only comparator figure the GPN paper prints for Figure 6D
Context-only references
DNA language models are powerful predictors of genome-wide variant effects (PNAS 2023)

Original source ↗

Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined

Version: PNAS 120(44) e2311219120, published 26 October 2023; Europe PMC full text JATS XML of PMC10622914
Retrieved: 2026-11-16T00:29:00Z

not individually reviewed

No individual claim review recorded

Audit details

Field: name

Source artifact SHA-256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0

Hash scope: Hash scope not separately documented; inspect source record

Format: JATS XML

Sources and history

Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Record review: source checked

1 source record and release historyDownload this release (gzip)
Technical metadata and extraction receipts

Stable ID: gpn-paper-20261116-claim-comparator-bound-gwas

areas
dna-genomes
contexts
research
field
comparator_bound
review
artifact sha256: 8ff2184c07f5e6807af0b9d5103d669e1920e735ab5a4b1ea856c070077ae1e0; method: independent-cell-check; automated-source-review; source-hash-verification; method note: Independent review pass by a different agent from the extractor, with its own script (review/recheck_values.py), which does not import extract/parse_values.py and does not read extract/values.json. The published article XML and the bioRxiv details API response were re-downloaded and matched their pinned hashes; the SI Appendix PDF was re-downloaded as the member of a freshly built Europe PMC zip (a third distinct zip hash, c7a1b20e8796c4bd384ba6f0308134e32a66e40dc881b0c1e3d0201da26e8498) and the PDF member matched. Every archived gz in artifacts/ decompresses to the hash its source record pins, and the text layer in extract/ regenerates byte for byte from the archived PDF with pdftotext -layout, poppler 26.08.0. npm run batch -- check-values reproduced the extractor's figures: 6 in_cell, 17 locator_not_parsed, no overclaimed_in_row. Each claim was read against its own source_locator in the re-retrieved artifacts. Two locators did not cover the whole claim and were corrected in this pass: the comparator bound claim now also names Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', where phyloP x LD, abs(phyloP) x LD, phastCons x LD and the baseline LD Score are defined, and the motif claim now also names Materials and Methods, 'Motif Analysis', where the 1,000 bp promoter window and the repeat and coding exon filter are printed. The central finding was confirmed independently: the whole JATS document holds zero table-wrap and zero table elements, and the SI Appendix figure pages print no comparator value in their text layer, only axis ticks, GPN score bin edges, threshold quantiles, method legends and the per-class variant counts of the Figure S9 subplot titles.; note: source_locator extended in this review pass. The bound itself is printed in the Results sentence, but the four comparator methods the claim names are defined in Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction' ('We similarly defined phyloP x LD ..., abs(phyloP) x LD and phastCons x LD. We considered the baseline LD Score'), which the locator did not name. The Figure 6 D caption names no method.; retrieval url: https://www.ebi.ac.uk/europepmc/webservices/rest/PMC10622914/fullTextXML; reviewed at: 2026-11-16T01:30:00Z; reviewer: claude; reviewer note: Claude review agent, independent of the extractor; no human review claimed. Transcription was checked against the pinned artifacts; nothing was reproduced and no value was recomputed.
source locator
Results, 'Enrichment of GWAS hits in regions with low GPN scores', sentence beginning "In particular, by analyzing odds ratios"; Figure 6 D caption; Materials and Methods, 'Variant Effect Prediction', sentences beginning "We similarly defined phyloP x LD" and "We considered the baseline LD Score", where the four comparator methods are defined
value
"while less than 7.5-fold enrichment was observed for other methods (Fig. 6D)". The other methods are phyloP x LD, phastCons x LD, abs(phyloP) x LD and LD Score. Figure 6D prints no per-method value in its text layer, so none is recorded.
Related records

Suggest a correction