Clustering hyperparameters were selected on the reported metrics
Selection bias of BacBench strain clustering, adjusted Rand index
The Leiden resolution and neighbour count were chosen as the combination that maximised the mean of the adjusted Rand index, normalised mutual information and average silhouette width at the species level, on the same genomes the table reports
The reported clustering values are the best of a hyperparameter grid scored on the same data, so they are not held-out measurements and overstate what a fresh dataset would give.
Evidence
Source checking verifies the cited claim or transcription. It does not establish independent reproduction.
Evidence table
Inspect claims, sources and review details
Trace each statement to its source and review. A context-only reference supports the record generally; it does not verify an individual field. Source checking does not reproduce an experiment.
One row per statement and cited source. Multiple citations are not independent evaluations. Shared locators are labelled explicitly.
7 evidence rows matching the loaded filters
| Property and statement | Original source and location | Review and provenance |
|---|---|---|
| Claimed field selection_bias Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
| Rationale The reported clustering values are the best of a hyperparameter grid scored on the same data, so they are not held-out measurements and overstate what a fresh dataset would give. Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
| Source location Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
| Claimed value The Leiden resolution and neighbour count were chosen as the combination that maximised the mean of the adjusted Rand index, normalised mutual information and average silhouette width at the species level, on the same genomes the table reports Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
| Description The reported clustering values are the best of a hyperparameter grid scored on the same data, so they are not held-out measurements and overstate what a fresh dataset would give. Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
| Relationship: subject bacformer-20261115-protocol-strain-clustering-ari Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
| Name Clustering hyperparameters were selected on the reported metrics Context-only references | Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level' Version: Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19 | not individually reviewed No individual claim review recorded Audit detailsField: Source artifact SHA-256: Hash scope: The hash is of one download. bioRxiv regenerates this PDF on request, so the container bytes differ between downloads: a second download minutes later gave 08fcc83af256845d942345fc6b63c64911878733acd028edab5e9307d63319db. The pdftotext -layout text layer of both downloads is byte-identical (SHA-256 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2), and that text layer, archived gzipped in artifacts/ with SHA-256 0afdefd78a410d036d1c4f17e33bdf481e8d76241ee02f4c84c7c4be91ee72aa, is what every extracted value was read from. |
Sources and history
Release 2026-11-21-c8bea25e5abb · Record review: source checked
1 source record and release history
- Bacformer preprint, bioRxiv 2025.07.20.665723 version 3 · Original source · Version 3, posted 17 August 2026 according to the page banner; the bioRxiv API lists version 3 with date 2026-08-19
Technical metadata and extraction receipts
Stable ID: bacformer-20261115-claim-strain-clustering-selection
- areas
- microbes-communities
- contexts
- research
- field
- selection_bias
- rationale
- The reported clustering values are the best of a hyperparameter grid scored on the same data, so they are not held-out measurements and overstate what a fresh dataset would give.
- review
- artifact sha256: 86636e89b167d7304b3a83ee7f159cad0a9bdbe97019588ce836087b8fe3b0b2; method: transcription; pdf-text-parse; source-hash-verification; ai-assisted-source-review; method note: Independent review pass. Each source artifact was retrieved again at review time and its SHA-256 compared with the source record; the quoted statement was then read at the recorded locator and compared with the recorded value. Access states were rechecked rather than taken from notes.md.; note: Statement re-read against the version 3 preprint. The PDF's container bytes differ on every download, so the artifact checked is its pdftotext -layout text layer, which two fresh downloads reproduce byte for byte and which the archived copy in artifacts/ decompresses to. Checked and left as a claim and a protocol limitation, with no evidence concern. The selection applies identically to all six systems in Table S12, so it biases the level of every value and not their comparison with each other; it is a property of the protocol, which records it, rather than a defect that should withhold the table.; retrieval url: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2025.07.20.665723v3.full.pdf; reviewed at: 2026-11-15T23:55:00Z; reviewer: claude; reviewer note: Claude (Opus 5) review agent, independent of the agent that extracted this batch; no human review claimed. Transcription was checked against the pinned sources. Nothing was reproduced and no value was recomputed.
- source locator
- Preprint Methods 'Strain clustering': 'We then retained the combination of resolution and number of neighbours that maximised the mean of the three metrics described above (ARI, NMI and ASW) at the species level'
- value
- The Leiden resolution and neighbour count were chosen as the combination that maximised the mean of the adjusted Rand index, normalised mutual information and average silhouette width at the species level, on the same genomes the table reports